Spraying particles in the upper atmosphere to reflect sunlight sounds like a crazy way of dealing with climate change, yet an increasing number of concerned physical and social scientists believe we need to research it.
Solar geoengineering refers to climate interventions which deliberately reflect solar radiation to counter the effects of human-caused climate change. The most commonly discussed methods are marine cloud brightening - which involves spraying sea salt in the lower atmosphere to increase the reflectivity of clouds that hang over the ocean - and stratospheric aerosol injection - which involves adding aerosols in the upper atmosphere around 20 km high and reflect ~1% of the incoming sunlight. The idea for the latter came after observing Mount Pinatubo’s eruption in 1991 and the following decrease in Earth's surface temperature. Shortly thereafter, scientists started using the same climate models used to predict the effects of climate change to see what would happen if we injected particles in the upper stratosphere. They show that modest amounts of stratospheric aerosol injection can reduce the impacts of global warming. However, there are many risks and uncertainties: some physical risks remain even in the optimal deployment scenario, and some risks are due to how societies will deploy this technology.
Why cutting emissions is not enough.
The figure below shows how much carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions have to decrease in the next few decades with associated probabilities of staying below a certain temperature target. I struggle to see a fair, democratic, and peaceful way of going down the green line, which would only give us a 66% chance of staying below 1.5 degrees C.
Calculated by Zeke Hausfather using IPCC SR15 report carbon budgets.
Source: https://twitter.com/hausfath/status/1309191498018164736/
Solar geoengineering should not be conceived as an alternative to cutting emissions. Given that even 2 degrees of warming might lead to disastrous consequences in at least some parts of the world, the prospect of a nation or other actor engaging in some form of solar geoengineering is very possible. Hence, whether or not one thinks it is a good idea to use it, it is in our best interest to understand how solar geoengineering may affect the climate.
Climate model evidence that solar geoengineering could moderate climate change impacts
Figure 2: Halving warming with stratospheric aerosol injection moderates key climate hazards. Reproduced from Irvine and Keith (2020) (their figure 6).
Figure 2 shows results from a comprehensive climate model where warming from increasing carbon dioxide is halved using stratospheric aerosol injection. The metrics are surface air temperature (T), maximum annual temperature (Tx), precipitation minus evaporation (P-E), and maximum precipitation (Px). Blue colors indicate that the geoengineered climate is closer to the preindustrial compared to the high carbon dioxide climate, whereas red colors indicate that changes are exacerbated with geoengineering. This shows that stratospheric aerosol injection has the potential to reduce climate harms in almost all the regions of the world, and presents a strong case for why we should take solar geoengineering seriously. One may worry however, that these results depend on the climate model itself or how they did the simulation. This justifies doing more work using different climate models, but also to do outdoor experiments to check the validity of our models.
Optimal scenario of solar geoengineering use
The diagram below shows a conceptual understanding of how emission cuts, carbon dioxide removal (or “negative emissions”), and solar geoengineering affect climate impacts in a scenario where solar geoengineering is used wisely. Climate impacts, such as sea level rise, heat waves, and changes in the rain and drought patterns, are plotted as a function of time and are considered to be approximately proportional to surface temperature change. If we continue emitting greenhouse gases (red, “business as usual”), the Earth will continue to warm and climate impacts will get worse. If we cut emissions aggressively (black), the Earth stops warming once we reach carbon neutrality but will not cool. It is only by removing greenhouse gases (green) that the surface temperature and climate impacts will start going back down to preindustrial levels. Given that greenhouse gas removal is slow and expensive using current technology, solar geoengineering is thought of as a temporary measure to reduce climate impacts while we bring greenhouse gas concentrations back down to safe levels.
Conceptual understanding of how emission cuts, carbon dioxide removal, and solar geoengineering affect climate impacts in the “peak-shaving” scenario. Reproduced from MacMartin et al. 2018 (their figure 1).
Even in this best case scenario, there are many physical risks associated with stratospheric aerosol injection. Injecting aerosols does not simply “cancel” the warming from carbon dioxide, the sum of high carbon dioxide and stratospheric aerosols leads to a different climate, which is likely safer than one with just high carbon dioxide. The injected particles may interact with stratospheric ozone and cause ozone loss. They may also affect patterns of precipitation. Furthermore, their injection does not get rid of the excess carbon dioxide in the atmosphere-ocean system, so the oceans will keep acidifying. Finally, a 2-3% reduction in insolation might affect solar energy generation and the growing of plants. It is important to emphasize that many of these risks are not well understood and need more research.
Even though earlier influential studies showed that stratospheric aerosol injection may affect the Asian and African summer monsoon, more recent research reveals that climate impacts of solar geoengineering depend a lot on what kind of reflectant is used, where, when, and how much aerosol is deployed in the upper atmosphere. Solar geoengineering can be thought of as a design problem: by choosing how to deploy it, we can to some extent choose the climate outcome. However, there is a lot of uncertainty involved and more research to do.
Difference between idealized scenario and real politics
A central supposition of the optimal scenario for solar geoengineering use described above is the existence of an omniscient rational planner that would use stratospheric aerosol injection wisely, moderately, and temporarily, all while we remove CO2 from the atmosphere. It assumes that the deployment will last as long as CO2 levels are at an unsafe level - potentially centuries given how slow removing greenhouse gases currently is. This rational long-term global cooperation seems impossible to many.
Another concern is that if the impacts of climate change are curtailed with solar geoengineering, this might reduce the impetus to cut emissions (called “moral hazard” in the literature). Indeed, investment into solar geoengineering research and development might take resources away from scientists working on emission cuts, and the political will for emission reductions might be attenuated if the climate change impacts do not materialize. However, the same arguments were used against adaptation to climate change. And, given the drastic nature of solar geoengineering and the associated risks, it might actually increase the political will to reduce emissions. And, the costs of “adapting” may be largely underestimated, as large parts of the world may become uninhabitable due to heatwaves, sea level rise, extreme weather, droughts, and floods.
Moreover, some people argue that Northern countries such as Canada and Russia will benefit from climate change by having much warmer winters. Indeed, warming from increased carbon dioxide is amplified in the Arctic, especially during winter. The decline in Arctic sea ice also opens up the Arctic for resource extraction and new shipping routes. Hence, there may not be a consensus on the desired climate outcome of solar geoengineering. Even though the climate outcome depends on the climate intervention strategy used, it remains to be seen how much the climate of a given area can be "optimized".
For some, solar geoengineering is merely seen as a technology that supports the status quo. They say it will be used by the powerful to continue emitting greenhouse gases and stabilize the climate. I am also very concerned with the unjust concentration of political and economic power. Capitalism is an undemocratic economic system where a minority owns the means of production and decides on the what, where, and how of economic production. This system devalues human lives enough that I would push for for a different set of rules regardless of whether climate change was an issue. If one’s opposition to capitalism depends on the urgency of the climate crisis, then I understand how solar geoengineering, which may be used to give us more time to cut emissions and remove CO2, might be seen as reactionary. It is, I believe, possible to embrace the potential of solar geoengineering while also fighting the unjust concentration of political and economic power.
Finally, it seems some just have a gut-level reaction that solar geoengineering should just not be talked about, as it counts as manipulating nature. Emitting carbon dioxide and aerosols in the lower atmosphere are also changing the climate, but involuntarily. Choosing to do it to benefit mankind would be “playing god”. To be honest, I had the same initial gut reaction. But, for all the reasons above, I don't think there is an easy way out of the climate problem. Hence we need all the options on the table including solar geoengineering. A future without solar geoengineering will somewhere between bad and very very bad, whereas a future with solar geoengineering has the potential (but no guarantee!) to be OK.